Let’s just take for comparison, the Spiderverse series. I do admit that the graphics and artwork were pretty good. Maybe if I was a kid, I would’ve enjoyed it.

But anything from Marvel (or DC, any other large corpo-studio) feels like something that has been overused, that it isn’t original. It’s like Wattpad going mainstream - I would rather listen to a terrible story by the original author than a good adaptation, because every adaption does the job of not explaining contexts, and leaves for the consumers to go back to the original source, leading to more disappointment.

There’s cringe pop-references and lazy, overused sci-fi troupes like time travel, parallel universe, gene mutation, scientist explaining the “fake science” about worm holes, etc - all of which makes the movie so mushy. When I watch a movie, I don’t want to engage in any core research. I want that chapter to close when I finish watching it. Like for example, just look at Interstellar. This movie just takes ten minutes to explain most of the science stuff, and the rest is left to visual perception about how the laws of physics are bent in this unique environment. And the rest is left for me to pursue the subject later in my own personal convenience.

Sure, Howl’s Moving Castle by Studio Ghibli does not respect the original novel by Diana Jones faithfully, but that movie was simply magical, and made me so engrossed in reading the original novel. I had butterflies in my tummy when I saw the air-walking scene involving Howl and Sophie, when Calcifer turns the house in a fast-moving vehicle, and when Howl makes his first contract with Calcifer, because they were so damn good. I know enough, and if I need to, I can go into detail about stuff I want to understand more. Like for example, the birthplace of Howl, how he ended up in the parallel world where Ingary exists, etc.

There’s moving trees, there’s breeze, and when I see the movie, I feel like as if I can sense fresh air going inside my lungs, with some hints of saline, which is how sea breezes smell, that I can perceive the petrichor when it rains, and the strong-yet-hypnotic scent of a witchs’ brew and concoctions.

Just making this rant because I’m annoyed with pop-culture fanboys who rely on trend as a metrics to judge other’s taste, and that I want a safe-space to discuss about good artists and story tellers.

Personally, I feel like comics or similar media of any form (mangha, manhwa, light novel, etc) sucks as a form of story-telling, perhaps it is because they’re too accessible to the point that there’s cost-cutting, then there’s the dreaded fan service, which is always very sexual and objectifies the character of interest (which is something I hate so much). I equate it to fast media, something that is hyper-capitalist and obsessed with profit - stick to a trend, mass-produce it, and make money for investors.

Compared to something that is constrained to having no form of visual or auditory sensations and relies on imaginative thinking and careful writing - which is where novelists excel at, or when there’s no such restrictions, there’s a burden of showing the best art, the best world-building, and the reduction of complexity, which good artists and story tellers do so damn well.

  • itappearsthat [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    edit-2
    16 days ago

    Yes, a lot of stuff that has been produced recently is garbage. As with all art time is the greatest filter. If you watch movies on just a 10 year delay you can totally ignore a lot of crap that is just straight up forgotten. Some people treat movies & shows like live sports where you have to watch things so you can participate in social media discussions about them. If you don’t care about that then there is no reason to watch these movies. There is probably more incredible art released in just the past 40 years than you can reasonably appreciate in an entire lifetime, even sticking to only the great stuff.

    For myself I stick to books & single-player games. I don’t know, movies and shows are just not a convenient format. I feel like I have to watch a movie in a single sitting. Two hours is my entire evening’s worth of free time pretty much.

  • PKMKII [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    17 days ago

    Adaptations and remakes aren’t anything new to pop culture. The golden age of cinema is full of novel adaptations and remakes of prior films. Folklore comes from generations of people retelling the same stories. But those were people with limited scope and no media to record their tales. Now we have the sort of global culture where nearly countless tales can be adapted.

    But they don’t. The problem isn’t that Marvel and DC and Star Wars get adapted or have new iterations, it’s that those are the only goddamn things that get adapted. It’s not because there’s stories there that someone feels passionate about or that enough time has passed since the last version that the new standards of film making can give it a fresh spin. It’s because they know those are the franchises that have a built-in baseline of boys and young men that will sit their asses in seats. And because there’s so many being made at any time, when one of them happens to be good it doesn’t feel like a result of strong artistic vision, it feels like the monkeys at the typewriters got one right for once.

    And even when something actually novel breaks through, oh god do they rush to pump out derivative copies. All those middling GoT-esque shows that got rushed through production to cash in.

  • ndondo@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    16 days ago

    Imo not everything is for everybody and thats ok.

    If marvel movies arent your thing just dont watch them, theres too much good media out there for this to be a problem.

    And i think trends are moving away from the marvel style movies anyways. Has there even been one in theatres this year? That studio that made everything everywhere all at once has been putting out great stuff.

    Have you tried Arcane? Its a video game adaptation executed extremely well.